RIGGINS et al v. HOLSTEN et al - Page 49



          Interference 103,685                                                          
                    13. [O]n March 26, 1990, Dr. Holsten discussed                      
               with co-inventor Nigel Neely the possibility of                          
               using particular, alternative classes of chemicals as                    
               carriers in dyeing aramid fabrics and including the                      
               possible use of unsubstituted and mono N-substituted                     
               amides . . . .                                                           
                    14.  Holsten recorded his observations from the                     
               discussions at page 37 of his notebook number 216                        
               (Holsten Ex. 6) dated on March 27, 1990 and witnessed                    
               by Michael Simmons . . . on the same date.  The                          
               recorded observations by Holsten include the following:                  
                    In discussions with Nigel Neely on March 26th, we                   
                    revealed similar ideas to each other in that we had                 
                    both wondered if unsubstituted and mono-N-substituted               
                    amides might function as basic dye carriers in the                  
                    dyeing of aromatic polyamides.  Included in such                    
                    categories would be benzamide and benzanilide,                      
                    both crystalline products with limited or no                        
                    significant water solubility . . . .  Based upon                    
                    our conversation Nigel Neely ordered samples of                     
                    acetamide[,] benzamide and benzaniline . . . for                    
                    evaluation singly or in combination as basic dye                    
                    carriers useful dyeing aromatic polyamides.                         
               Holsten Ex. 6, N.B. 216, p. 37 (3/27/90) . . . .                         
                    . . . . .                                                           
                    16. [O]n April 5, 1990, Holsten recorded the                        
               additional observation that N,N-diethyl(m-toluamide)                     
               might additionally be used as a carrier for use in                       
               dyeing aromatic polyamide fibers or fabrics . . . .                      
               Holsten Ex. 7, N.B. 216, p. 47 (4/5/90).  The notebook                   
               entry also reflects a disclosure and discussion of the                   
               additional proposed use of N,N-dimethylbenzamide and                     
               benzanilide, additional N-substituted and disubstituted                  
               aromatic carbonamides as candidate dye carriers, as                      
               described to and discussed with Neely as well. . . . .                   
                    17.  Based on the discussions between Holsten and                   
               Neely, a series of laboratory dyeings were performed at                  
               their direction by . . . Moses Smith, Jr., including                     
               experiments using benzamide and benzanilide . . . as                     
               recorded by Smith on March 30, 1990 (Holsten Ex. 10)                     
                                         -49-                                           




Page:  Previous  42  43  44  45  46  47  48  49  50  51  52  53  54  55  56  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007