Ex parte VAL et al. - Page 5




          Appeal No. 1999-0878                                                        
          Application 08/182,093                                                      

          plate 80 is spaced from the surface of the chip and is not an               
          "electrically insulating material directly coating a surface                
          of the at least one chip" (emphasis added) (claim 14) or                    
          "electrically insulating means directly coating a surface of                
          the at least one chip" (emphasis added) (claim 22); and                     
          (2) the ends of the S-shaped wires 84 pass through connector                
          plate 80 and a solder connection is made to each power                      
          post 64, signal post 67, and ground post 72 (col. 4, line 67                
          to col. 5, line 1) and, thus, there is no "metallized contact               
          formed on an outside surface of said first electrically                     
          insulating material" (claim 14) or "metallized contact means                
          formed on an outside surface of said first electrically                     
          insulating means" (claim 22).                                               
               The Examiner concludes in the final rejection (FR2):  "It              
          would [have] be[en] considered obvious to one having ordinary               
          skill in this art to form insulating layer 18 [sic, 80]                     
          directly on the surface [of] chip 16 [sic, 18] because                      
          insulating substrates [sic, layers?] formed directly on chip                
          surfaces are not new in this art and are typically provided                 
          thereon."                                                                   



                                        - 5 -                                         





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007