Ex Parte RODDY - Page 4







              Appeal No. 1999-1452                                                                                        
              Application 08/436,830                                                                                      



              indicative of terminology associated with OOP.  The prior art discussion at column 1 of                     
              Berry is instructive as to setting an additional context under which Berry’s teachings                      
              must be viewed.  This would include user interfaces utilizing existing visual                               
              programming products to allow users to visually create simple event-action sequences                        
              with respect to source objects and target objects.  These are all discussed in the                          
              context of inserting, deleting, clearing, etc., functions associated with normal editing                    
              operations by a programmer.  In this sense, the context of Berry may be viewed as a                         
              program editor for modifying existing programs in OOP.  Berry teaches the use of                            
              graphical user interfaces (GUIs) to link objects in OOP.   Although not explicitly teaching                 
              that the GUI environment is Windows-based,  Figures 2-6 are clearly suggestive of that                      
              in addition to the ability of the user to use the user interface adaptor 22 in Figure 1 by                  
              the actuation of the mouse 26 and keyboard 24 to effect the GUI functions depicted in                       
              these figures.   These functions also include conventional Windows-type drag and                            
              release operations for manipulating graphical objects such as those displayed in the                        
              various figures.                                                                                            
                     On the other hand, in a more specific context, Pazel teaches that a Windows-                         
              type environment is utilized with its attendant graphical user interfaces to simplify                       
              software programming development and debugging and even to correct software                                 

                                                            4                                                             





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007