VISSER et al v. HOFVANDER et al - Page 83




          Interference 103,579                                                        
          PGBSS gene in the antisense direction do not read on, or                    
          anticipate, inserts comprising the DNA segment of the PGBSS gene            
          in the antisense direction.  As we interpret the subject matter             
          the parties to this interference claim, inserts comprising a DNA            
          segment of the PGBSS gene in the antisense direction also do not            
          read on, or anticipate, inserts comprising a DNA fragment of a              
          DNA segment of the PGBSS gene in the antisense direction.                   
               Having considered all the evidence in this case, we find               
          that none of Hofvander’s 342 bp SEQ ID No. 1 which excludes                 
          substantially all of the HindIII-SpeI segment of the coding                 
          region of the PGBSS gene, Hofvander’s 2549 bp SEQ ID NO. 2 which            
          includes all but the SstI-SpeI segment of the HindIII-SpeI                  
          segment of the coding region of the PGBSS gene, and 492 bp SEQ ID           
          No. 3 which includes no more than the SstI-SpeI segment of the              
          HindIII-SpeI segment of the coding region of the PGBSS gene,                
          anticipates the Visser’s full length PGBSS genomic DNA sequence             
          coding for PGBSS including all of the HindIII-SpeI segment of the           
          coding region of the PGBSS gene.                                            
               In this case, less complex chemical codes inserted in the              
          potato genome in the antisense direction do not anticipate more             
          complex chemical codes inserted in the potato genome in the                 


          antisense direction, and vice versa.  On their face, Hofvander’s            
          claims do not anticipate Visser’s claims, and vice versa.                   
                                        -83-                                          





Page:  Previous  76  77  78  79  80  81  82  83  84  85  86  87  88  89  90  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007