Ex Parte KATSURA et al - Page 9



          Appeal No. 2000-0064                                                        
          Application 08/625,241                                                      

          argue that the portion of Stone relied on by the examiner does              
          not support the parallel processing and transferring of                     
          information as claimed.  With respect to claims 31 and 32,                  
          appellants additionally argue that the applied prior art does not           
          teach or suggest the first and second registers as claimed.  With           
          respect to claim 33, appellants additionally argue that the                 
          examiner has failed to properly apply a “means-plus-function”               
          analysis to this claim [brief, pages 5-12].                                 
          The examiner responds that the first bus in the claimed                     
          invention corresponds to the communication link in Fleming.  The            
          examiner notes that the claim language on appeal now is similar             
          to claim language considered by the Board in a previous decision.           
          The examiner also responds that the processing and transferring             
          steps in Fleming are performed in parallel.  The examiner also              
          notes that Stone teaches that parallel processing was well known.           
          With respect to claims 31 and 32, the examiner takes Official               
          Notice that registers for storing addresses were well known, and            
          the examiner cites a Motorola manual for support of this                    
          position.  With respect to claim 33, the examiner responds that             
          Fleming in view of Stone discloses the same processing as claim             



                                          9                                           




Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007