Ex Parte HSIA et al - Page 6



          Appeal No. 2000-1057                                                        
          Application 09/016,100                                                      


                 1.  The step of reacting metal with a polysilicon                    
                            layer to form metal silicide                              
                    Grewal teaches a plasma etching method wherein a first            
          layer of a doped polysilicon is deposited onto a substrate                  
          followed by depositing a conductive refractory metal silicide               
          layer.  Grewal, column 3, line 66-column 4, line 2.  According to           
          the examiner, “Grewal is not particular about the method for                
          forming metal silicide.”  Examiner’s Answer, page 4.  Thus, it              
          would have been obvious to have formed the metal silicide by                
          reacting metal with a polysilicon layer in view of Hayashi’s                
          disclosure  of a step of reacting metal with a conductive layer             
          in a semi-conductor fabrication technique.  Id., pages 3-4, see             
          page 6.                                                                     
                    Appellants argue that Grewal specifically teaches                 
          that the refractory metal silicide layer is “deposited, as by               
          sputtering.”  Reply Brief, Paper No. 10, received August 22,                
          2000, page 2 (referencing Grewal, columns 3 and 4).  Moreover,              
          appellants note that in Hayashi, the step of reacting metal with            
          a conductive layer is utilized for an entirely different purpose.           
          In particular, appellants note that:                                        


                                          6                                           




Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007