Ex Parte PORZILLI - Page 2




             Appeal No. 2001-0913                                                                                  
             Application No. 09/002,058                                                                            


                    Claim 1 is the only independent claim on appeal, and it reads as follows:                      
             1.     A string instrument comprising:                                                                
                    a first body having a resonant chamber;                                                        
                    a plurality of strings each manifesting a tone of a different frequency secured to and external
             to the body and over the chamber for producing first acoustical waves in a range of frequencies, the  
             chamber exhibiting second acoustic waves in a range of frequencies responsive to and                  
             corresponding to the first waves; and                                                                 
                    acoustic wave enhancing means coupled to the body and to the chamber for selectively           
             enhancing only the acoustic waves of the lower portion of the range of frequencies of the second      
             waves.                                                                                                
                    The references relied on by the examiner are:                                                  
             Dunham                                   1,303,466                        May 13, 1919                
             Kalaf                                    1,455,916                        May 23, 1923                
             Redlinger2                               1,635,502                        Jul.  12, 1927              
             Pedersen                                 1,721,710                        Jul.  23, 1929              
             Newton                                   2,953,052                        Sep. 20, 1960               
             Doschek                                  3,101,810                        Aug. 27, 1963               
             Desmond                                  3,524,377                        Aug. 18, 1970               
             Kasha                                    4,079,654                        Mar. 21, 1978               


             McGill                                   5,780,758                        Jul.   14, 1998             
                                                                   (effective filing date Aug. 11, 1994)           
             de Cristofaro3                           FR 370, 137                      Jan.  29, 1907              
             (French Patent Application)                                                                           


                    2 Although this reference is not listed in the prior art of record (answer, page 4), it is     
             relied on by the examiner to reject several claims on appeal (answer, pages 5 and 6).                 
                    3 A copy of the translation of this reference is attached.                                     
                                                        2                                                          





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007