ELI LIILY & CO. vs. CAMERON et al - Page 15




                                                                                              Interference No. 104,101                   
                                                                                                                Page 15                  
                1211, Bates No. 3069; Sheet 469590 and 469823).  Specifically, each of the submission sheets                             
                depicts the structure of the compound that Mr. Cullinan believed that he had produced.  Each                             
                submission sheet bears a notation that corresponds to the specific notebook page identified by                           
                Mr. Cullinan.                                                                                                            


                F34. Physical chemistry submission sheet 469307 contains the number “459” next to the                                    
                notation “M.S.”2  Submission sheet 469823 contains the number “460 ” next to the notation                                
                “M.S.”  Moreover, submission sheets 469590 and 469823 both contain what appears to be                                    
                elemental analysis results.  These notations and the data they represent fail to confirm that the                        
                depicted structure was the specific structure tested.  Simply put, the data conforms to a variety of                     
                structures and is not limited to the depicted structure.                                                                 


                        Lilly Research Record Submission Sheet for Compound Serial No. 311583                                            
                F35.    Mr. F. William Bell is an Assistant Senior Chemist at Lilly.  (EX 1159, ¶ 2).  Mr. Bell has                      
                worked in Lilly’s Research Records Department from April 1991 to the present.  (EX 1159, ¶ 2).                           
                Mr. Bell testified that the Serial No. 311583 submission sheet is a true and accurate copy                               
                obtained from the Research Records microfilm archive. (EX 1159, ¶ 7).                                                    







                        2We understand the notation “M.S.” to refer to mass spectroscopy.                                                





Page:  Previous  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  16  17  18  19  20  21  22  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007