EDWARDS et al. V. LEVEEN - Page 16



       S                                                                                       


          Interference No. 104,290                                                             



          although the ablation apparatus would be physically smaller.                         

          Id. Fox describes the ablation apparatus in paragraph 4 of                           
          Exhibit 1173. Fox states that the "curved wire electrodes                            

          . . . would be deployed through a cannula by holding the cannula                     

                     In use, the cannula shaft can be held by a forceps or                     

          the operator's fingers. LR31, 47. Notwithstanding Edwards'                           

          argument that the cannula is not a handle, we construe the count                     

          term "handle" broadly, and note that the cannula can be held with                    

          a portion of the operator's hand.                                                    
                     LeVeen gave Fox a Dormier basket with which Fox was to                    

          fashion a prototype of the invention. LX-1173, $5. A Dormier                         
          basket is a surgical instrument used to retrieve concretions such                    

          as kidney stones or gallstones. LR91. LX-1127 is a photograph                        
          of a Dormier basket. The distal end of the Dormier basket was                        

          cut off, and the stainless steel spring wires were everted.                          

          LeVeen sketched this shape of the wires in EX-5144. The sketch                       

          shows that the four stainless steel wires were bent generally in                     
          the shape of one-half of a hyperboloid with the open end of the                      

          hyperboloid positioned distally. The everted wires of the basket                     
          become the deployable electrodes when the probe is inserted in                       

          a cannula. The cannula used on the orototype was 16 gauge.                           



                                              16                                               







Page:  Previous  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  16  17  18  19  20  21  22  23  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007