Ex Parte PAFF - Page 22




          Appeal No. 1998-0872                                                        
          Application No. 08/438,479                                Page 22           


          the feature of having the operator being able to select a target            
          on a graphical image for viewing.  From our review of Smart, we             
          agree with the examiner that in Smart (page 1), an operator can             
          select any target for surveillance because the system allows the            
          operator to "readily pan and zoom into any of the Laboratory                
          buildings and surrounding areas."  In addition (page 3) when an             
          alarm occurs, the cameras can be readily turned and focused on              
          the appropriate location.  Smart further discloses (page 3) that            
          incidents occur as a result of object state changes.  Figure 5              
          shows three active incidents prioritized and summarized on the              
          screen with a leader line from the incident summary box to the              
          appropriate position.  Selecting an incident with the mouse draws           
          an incident control menu that enables automatic pan and zoom [on            
          the map] to the correct location (pages 3 and 4). In addition               
          (id.), Smart discloses that "any video (possibly audio)                     
          associated with the incident can be automatically switched."  We            
          find from this disclosure of Smart, that upon three active                  
          incidents occurring, as in figure 5, an automatic zoom and pan to           
          the location on the map, i.e, the target area, with the highest             
          priority will occur.  By selection of one of the incidents by the           
          operator, the operator will be selecting one of the three target            
          areas.  Upon selection of the incident, any video associated with           







Page:  Previous  15  16  17  18  19  20  21  22  23  24  25  26  27  28  29  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007