Ex parte MIYATA - Page 8




          Appeal No. 1999-2640                                                         
          Application 08/918,267                                                       

          to us, how Fig. 6B (or anywhere else in Kato) shows generating               
          sets of numbers specifying the coordinates of the line                       
          segments.                                                                    
               The Examiner finds that generating positions is shown by                
          the mapping operation of Fig. 1, step 204.  We do not                        
          understand this finding.  Part of the problem is that we do                  
          not find the previous step of generating a plurality of line                 
          coordinates specifying the line segments and, thus, do not see               
          how Kato generates a position value for each position "in                    
          response to said line coordinates," as claimed.  The term                    
          "position value" in claim 1 refers to a value for each                       
          position of the line segment, presumably every pixel location                
          of the line segment, not every for every position in the                     
          coordinate range.  The mapping step 204 in Fig. 1 maps                       
          (transforms) a point on the texture picture of Fig. 6B to a                  
          point on the surface of the object as shown in Fig. 6C.  It is               
          not known how this relates to, or could be considered to                     
          disclose, generating a position value in response to line                    
          coordinates.                                                                 
               The Examiner appears to find that Kato discloses                        
          generating texture in Fig. 6C.  Figure 6C shows the result of                

                                        - 8 -                                          





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007