Ex Parte MCCARTHY - Page 5




          Appeal No. 2003-1195                                                        
          Application No. 08/526,339                                                  


          drain sections defined within the layer, a layer of oxide                   
          material adjacent the polysilicon, with holes therein containing            
          polysilicon, and a layer of n-type silicon having doped                     
          source/drain regions contacting the doped polysilicon.  The                 
          examiner cites Inoue as teaching, on the cover figure, a pair of            
          bridge regions 12/12' in contact with source/drain regions 4/5              
          and concludes therefrom that it would have been obvious “to                 
          provide bridge regions as taught by Inoue . . . in the device of            
          Spangler . . . in order to limit the electric field within the              
          channel region as desired by Inoue . . .” (answer, page 4).                 
               For his part, in discussing the combination of Spangler and            
          Inoue, at pages 7-8 of the brief, appellant does not argue that             
          there is any fault with the examiner’s interpretation of the                
          references or with the combination of references.  Instead,                 
          appellant merely relies on our earlier decision of July 31, 2000            
          (Paper No. 15), arguing that the examiner’s rejection is “in                
          conflict with points set forth” in that decision (brief, page 7).           
          Appellant states that since that decision was based on a broad              
          interpretation of the term “section” and that term no longer                
          appears in the claims, the rejection is improper.  While such an            
          argument would be valid if the examiner was basing the rejection            
          on the term “section,” this does not appear to be the basis for             


                                         -5-                                          




Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007