Ex Parte HILLMAN - Page 4




               Interference No. 104,436 Paper 98                                                                                    
               Shyamala v. IEllman Page 4                                                                                           
       [201 Dr. Shyamala directed Mr. Khoja to screen thousands of proteins randomly selected from a                                
               protein library to i dentify proteins interacting with MKK3 [1025 at 4-5; 10 1 02 at 31.                             
       [211 The screening involved inserting test sequences of complementary deoxyribonucleic acid                                  
               (cDNA) into yeast to produce test proteins and identifying successful interactions of test proteins                  
               w I ith MKK3 by a change in color [1025 at 4].                                                                       
       [22] According to Mr. Khoja, he analyzed the DNA of clones that demonstrated successful                                      
               interactions [1010 at 3].                                                                                            
       [23] A 20 February 1996 entry in Mr. Khoja's Notebook No. 7613 shows photographs of two gels                                 
               sorting insert cDNAs by size [ 10 10 at 4; 10 12 at 137].                                                            
       [24] According to Shyamala and Khoja, he identified several clones with 1.4 kilobase (kb) inserts of                         
               cDNA as being of interest [ 10 10 at 4. 1025 at 6].                                                                  
       [251 According to Mr. Khoja, the run in the lower photograph labeled B73 proved to code for what                             
               was later identified as MIP [fOIO at 41.                                                                             
       [26] Shyamala does not explain why, on 20 February 1996, 1.4 kb proteins were of particular interest                         
               or what significance Shyamala or Khoja ascribed to B73 on that date.                                                 
       [271 Mr. Khoja requested sequencing of clone 14b, which he states was B73 [1010 at 4).                                       
       (28] The notebook of Chun Ting Lee-Ng shows five forms labeled "Request for DNA Sequence"                                    
               from Hamid Khoja, one of which (top right) lists " 14B". The requests are initialed as received                      
               26 February 1996 [1014' at 163].                                                                                     


                      2 Declaration of Harniduddin Kboja.                                                                           
                      ' Lee-Ng Notebook No. 7468.                                                                                   






Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007