WAKALOPULOS et al. V. BILSTAD et al. - Page 16




                                  8. As illustrated in Figure 2, however, the components to be joined or                                                 
                                  assembled are normally arranged such that the motion required farjoining or                                            
                                  assembly is perpendicular to the motion imparted by the conveyor belt. Thus,                                           
                                  Figures 3, 5, 6, and 8, each of which illustrates a joining or assembly                                                
                                  operation, necessarily show a second direction of motion in which objects                                              
                                  may be moved while in the reactive volume. In each of these figures, the                                               
                                  conveyor as well as the mechanism responsible for the joining or assembly                                              
                                  motion have been suppressed in order to focus attention on the sequence of                                             
                                  steps which enable sterile connection to occur. Nonetheless, the existence of                                          
                                  these motions, as well as mechanisms that create them, would be obvious to                                             
                                  one skilled in the art.                                                                                                
                                  9. In addition to the two axes of motion (conveyance in and out of the                                                 
                                  reactive field and joining/assembling along a perpendicular axis) that are                                             
                                  present in the systems illustrated in Figures 3, 5, 6 and 8, several other                                             
                                  examples of distinct axes of motion may also be recognized in the '964                                                 
                                  application.                                                                                                           
                                  10. One such example is given onpage 8, lines 11-12 which describe "apair                                              
                                  of rotating tabs 72, 73 which help to maintain the alignment of ends 14 of                                             
                                  components 10, 12," and also in claim 46 which describes "a mechanism                                                  
                                  which brings the opened ends into aligned contact with each other while in                                             
                                  the active sterile field." These two examples describe mechanisms or devices                                           
                                  for alignment. The Random House Dictionary defines "align" as "to arrange                                              
                                  in a straight line," or "to bring into a line." The point is that, whereas the                                         
                                  main joining or assembly motion may occur along a single line, it is                                                   
                                  necessary to provide additional axes of motion so that the components may                                              
                                  be moved to that line. This concept is well-known to experts in robotics and                                           
                                  automated manufacturing. Williams, for instance, in his book "Manufacturing                                            
                                  Systems: an Introduction to the Technologies," discusses the problems of                                               
                                  jamming and wedging that may occur in parts mating due to angular and                                                  
                                  off-axis misalignment. Williams goes on to describe a device, the remote                                               
                                  center compliance, often used in automated systems to bring objects into                                               
                                  correct aligriment. Of course, many other techniques are known in the art for                                          
                                  establishing proper alignment. Similar discussions can be found in the books                                           
                                  by Asfahl and Sandler referenced above. In conclusion, by describing                                                   
                                  mechanisms capable of alignment, the '964 application inherently describes                                             
                                  mechanisms capable of moving objects along a plurality of axes.                                                        
                                  11. Figures 5A and 5B illustrate another type of complex motion involving                                              
                                  a plurality of axes. In Figure 5A, tabs 72 and 73 are shown enclosing the                                              
                                  sterile ends ofthetwo components to bejoined. Thesetabs are "peeled" away                                              
                                  by means of the rotary motion shown with arrows C and D in both Figures                                                
                                                                        -16-                                                                             







Page:  Previous  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  16  17  18  19  20  21  22  23  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007