Ex Parte HOLMANN et al - Page 6



          Appeal No. 2002-2330                                                        
          Application No. 09/116,260                                 Page 6           

          teachings.”  It is argued (brief, page 8) that Hagqvist merely              
          discloses a CPU which is fed address values, and that “nothing in           
          Hagqvist et al. shows, teaches or suggests a delayed instruction            
          includes a field for specifying a delay value and a first program           
          counter value is specified by the field of the delayed                      
          instruction as the delay value as claimed in claim 36.”  It is              
          further argued (brief, page 10) that Morrison merely discloses              
          totally coupling each processor element to a register during its            
          particular instruction firing time such that the instruction                
          firing time indicates the instruction execution timing.                     
          Appellants assert (id.) that nothing in Morrison shows, teaches             
          or suggests that the registers are for holding the value to be              
          compared with the program counter, and (brief, page 11) that                
          “Morrison et al. does not show, teach or suggest a delayed                  
          instruction, decoding a delayed instruction or determining a                
          coincidence between a value of a program counter and a first                
          program counter value specified by the field of a delay                     
          instruction as a delay value as claimed in claim 36.”                       
               From our review of Hagqvist and Morrison we find that                  
          Hagqvist is directed to a system for enabling a microprocessor to           
          efficiently branch to an alternate program source when a portion            
          of the program is superseded (col. 1, lines 8-10).  As shown in             





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007