Ex Parte MUNSIL et al - Page 2




              Appeal No. 2003-0957                                                                 Page 2                
              Application No. 09/074,074                                                                                 


                     Messages are included with each bill.  The space available on a standardized                        
              billing statement limits, however, the number of such messages that can be included.                       
              When all messages will not fit in the available space, the appellants explain, some                        
              messages are omitted "regardless of priority or importance."  (Id at 2.)  They assert,                     
              "[t]here is no known system for prioritizing the universe of messages that could appear                    
              on a bill and then print them on the available space according to their priority."  (Id.)                  


                     In contrast, the appellants' "bill messaging system . . .  prints . . . messages on a               
              customer billing statement according to a predetermined priority in the space allocated                    
              on the billing statement for such . . .  messages."  (Id.)  More specifically, billing                     
              personnel use the system to define a universe of available messages for a billing cycle.                   
              The personnel assign a priority to each message.  (Id. at 4.)                                              


                     Using data about each customer, the system qualifies each message; only                             
              messages relevant to a particular customer qualify for that customer.  The system then                     
              arranges all the qualifying messages according to priority.  Only those that fit on the bill               
              are eventually printed.  (Id.)                                                                             













Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007