Ex Parte GORDON et al - Page 14




                 Appeal No. 2003-1371                                                                                 Page 14                     
                 Application No. 09/186,856                                                                                                       


                 recognizes that "modifications to the preferred embodiment will be readily apparent to                                           
                 those skilled in the art, and [that] the generic principles defined [t]herein may be applied                                     
                 to other embodiments and applications. . . ."  Col. 4, ll. 60-64.                                                                


                         As explained regarding the prior point of contention, Stamper merges or splits a                                         
                 display in response to a player's location in an electronic game.  Furthermore, the                                              
                 reference discloses that its invention "increase[s] the realism of video games," col. 2,                                         
                 l. 27, and "increase[s] the ease and enjoyment of play. . . ."  Id. at ll. 29-30.  Because                                       
                 Naka invites modifications to, other applications of, and other embodiments of its dual-                                         
                 mode, electronic adventure game; and Stamper's merging or splitting in response to a                                             
                 player's location in an electronic game increases the realism, ease, and enjoyment of                                            
                 electronic games; we are persuaded that the references would have suggested merging                                              
                 or splitting a display in response to a player's location in the electronic game.                                                


                         As also explained regarding the prior point of contention, Curchod merges or                                             
                 splits a display in response to players' locations in an electronic game.  Furthermore,                                          
                 the reference discloses that its invention "increase[s] player throughput and efficient                                          
                 utilization of space, while still maintaining the quality of play."  Col. 2, ll. 15-17.                                          
                 Because Naka invites modifications to, other applications of, and other embodiments of                                           
                 its dual-mode, electronic adventure game, and Curchod's merging or splitting a display                                           








Page:  Previous  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  16  17  18  19  20  21  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007