Ex Parte BUECHLER et al - Page 8



          Appeal No. 2003-2049                                                        
          Application 09/003,090                                                      




               [s]ample information can include, for example, an                      
               identification of the sample and sample type, an                       
               identification of the patient from which the sample was                
               drawn, an indication of the test or tests to be performed              
               for the sample, as well as other data, as desired.                     
          We further note that Appellants’ specification states that a bar            
          code label is disposed on the assay device that includes encoded            
          information.  The specification states that                                 
               [t]he encoded information can include information such as,             
               for example, a patient I.D., an identification of the tests            
               to be performed on the sample, an identification of the                
               sample type, or other appropriate or pertinent information.            
          See pages 17 and 18 of Appellants’ specification.  However, we              
          have not found that this specification has overcome the heavy               
          burden of presumption that the claimed language “sample                     
          information,” has a different meaning from the ordinary meaning             
          that would be attributed to those versed by persons skilled in              
          the relevant art.  Thus, we find that the broadest and reasonable           
          interpretation of the claim language “sample information” must be           
          information that is dependent upon a particular sample.                     
               Turning to Betts, we find that Betts teaches a test system             
          which has three components: (1) one or more test reagents which             
          are specifically reactable with the particular substance or                 
                                          8                                           




Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007