Appeal No. 2004-0434 Application No. 09/836,686 Invention Appellant's invention relates to controlling the sharing of files by portable devices, and, more particularly, to controlling the sharing of music files by portable music players. A host system transfers at least one file to a first portable device. Along with the file, the host system transmits a transfer count associated with the file. The transfer count indicates the number of times that the first portable device may transfer the received file to other devices. Appellant's specification at page 1, lines 3-4, and page 5, line 24, to page 6, line 3. Claim 10 is representative of the claimed invention and is reproduced as follows: 10. A method, comprising: selecting at least one music file from a first portable device to transfer to a second portable device; transferring the music file to the second portable device; and transmitting a preselected transfer count to the second portable device, wherein the preselected transfer count is indicative of the number of times the second portable device may transfer the music file to one or more devices. References The references relied on by the Examiner are as follows: Abecassis 6,192,340 Feb. 20, 2001 (Filed Oct. 19, 1999) Berstis et al. (Berstis) 6,282,653 Aug. 28, 2001 (Filed May 15, 1998) 2Page: Previous 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 NextLast modified: November 3, 2007