Appeal No. 2004-1332 Application No. 10/010,691 signals and a controller 40, responsive to a plurality of control signals, for activating the pump based on a statistical analysis of control signal timing. This appealed subject matter is adequately represented by independent claim 1 which reads as follows: 1. A demand hot water recirculation system comprising: a hot water source; at least one plumbing fixture having a hot water inlet; a conduit, in fluid communication with said hot water source and the plumbing fixture hot water inlet, for enabling circulation of hot water from said hot water source to the plumbing future [sic, fixture] and return to said hot water source; a pump for circulating hot water through the conduit; a switch for generating control signals; and a controller, responsive to a pluralilty of control signals, for activating said pump based on a statistical analysis of control signal timing. The references set forth below are relied upon by the Examiner as evidence of obviousness: Barrett et al. (Barrett) 4,870,986 Oct. 3, 1989 Houlihan 5,775,372 July 7, 1998 22Page: Previous 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 NextLast modified: November 3, 2007