Ex Parte Goldstein - Page 29



           Appeal No. 2005-0823                                                                        
           Application No. 10/300,895                                             Page 29              


            Declaration and Exhibits have been considered for the information                          
            provided, it is given little weight as to the issue of when                                
            artisans were aware of the idea of going from weekly reporting to                          
            a shorter reporting period.                                                                
                  We turn next to the Declaration under 37 CFR § 1.132 of Mr.                          
            William Goldstein, filed October 16, 2003.  The Declaration of                             
            Mr. Goldstein, is a summary of an interview that took place with                           
            the examiner on June 11, 2003.  It is stated that in the                                   
            interview, the Brice patent '981 was discussed by Mr. Goldstein                            
            as being a real-time back-end accounting system.  Mr. Goldstein                            
            explained to the examiner that the Brice patent had no relevance                           
            as the reporting it described involved reporting of accounting                             
            data/ticket sales to the accounting system, not of the issuance                            
            of tickets.  When Travelocity issues tickets, real-time,                                   
            electronically, it creates a record in the GDS, that is                                    
            maintained in the GDS until the GDS is interfaced with the                                 
            accounting system.  Issuance of the ticket, however, is not                                
            reported to the airline or ARC in real-time, but rather as would                           
            any other travel agent.  The Declaration, on page 2, additionally                          
            states “I further explained that one of the examples I described                           
            in the application involved a system that performs batch                                   






Page:  Previous  22  23  24  25  26  27  28  29  30  31  32  33  34  35  36  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007