Ex Parte Lehman - Page 5



          Appeal No. 2005-2310                                                        
          Application 10/287,168                                                      

          out where Leonard limits the disclosure to a die to die system.             
          Regardless, the appellant’s claim 1 is not limited to a die to              
          die system.  The claim does not prevent the article believed to             
          be substantially free of defects and the article under inspection           
          from being dies on the same reticle.  In fact, the appellant’s              
          specification states that “in the case where only the die (and              
          not the inter die) area needs to be inspected, it is sufficient             
          to identify a master die, and use an image of the master die for            
          inspection of all dies on the reticles” (page 6, lines 24-26).              
               The appellant argues that Leonard does not store a reference           
          image but, rather, stores points extracted from the reference               
          image and then, to check the topology of a circuit under test,              
          regenerates the reference image from the stored points (reply               
          brief, page 7).  Leonard compresses the reference image data,               
          stores the compressed data, and regenerates the reference image             
          for comparison to the image under test (col. 9, lines 29-45).               
          The appellant likewise compresses the master image data when                
          recording the master image, and expands the master image data               
          when inspecting using the master (specification, page 7,                    
          lines 18-25; page 11, lines 16-20).                                         

          same reticle” (specification, page 2, lines 4-5).                           
                                          5                                           




Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007