Ex Parte Nagai - Page 9



         Appeal No. 2005-2437                                                                       
         Application No. 09/682,642                                                                 

         brush carrier.  As shown in Nagashima’s figure 1, the brush                                
         carrier is fixed to the second end cap.  The second end cap is                             
         connected by the threaded fasteners at the bottom part of the                              
         motor housing to the casing to the left of the threaded                                    
         fasteners.  That figure shows that the casing on the left side of                          
         the figure journals another shaft.                                                         
              Hence, we affirm the rejection of claim 12 and claim 13 that                          
         stands or falls therewith.                                                                 
                                     Claim 18                                                       
              The appellant argues that Isozumi’s ribs 21a of resinous                              
         bracket 21 have the sole purpose of preventing metal plates 22                             
         from being displaced when fasteners 14 are tightened, and that if                          
         the ribs were to provide any strength for the bearing the                                  
         reference would have said so (brief, page 10).                                             
              The appellant’s claim 18 requires that a second end cap is                            
         formed with stiffening ribs in the area of the plane bearing to                            
         minimize distortion loads thereon from threaded fasteners.                                 
         Isozumi discloses that metal plates 22 are engaged with ribs 21a                           
         of rear bracket 21 so that they may not be displaced when                                  
         through-bolts 14 are tightened (col. 4, lines 2-4).  Isozumi’s                             
         teachings that “the metal plates 22 are formed by using a plate                            

                                         9                                                          











Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007