Ex Parte Gerle et al - Page 2



          Appeal No. 2006-0436                                                        
          Application No. 09/942,465                                                  

          polyisocyanates blocked by pyrazole or pyrazole derivatives,                
          which are useful for “treating textiles, paper or leather.”  See            
          the specification, page 1.  Claims 1 and 8 are representative of            
          the appealed subject matter and read as follows:                            
               1. An NCO-containing reaction product blocked at the NCO               
          groups by 1-H-pyrazole or a derivative thereof, wherein the NCO-            
          containing reaction product is a reaction product of                        
          (A) one or more aromatic polyisocyanates,                                   
          (B) one or more NCO-reactive compounds containing sulfonate                 
          and/or tert-amino groups, and                                               
          (C) optionally, one or more further NCO-reactive compounds other            
          than compounds (B).                                                         
               8. A process for preparing a blocked NCO-containing reaction           
          products according to Claim 1 comprising reacting components (A),           
          (B), and optionally (C) and 1-H-pyrazole or a derivative thereof            
          as a blocking agent with each other at one and the same time or             
          in any desired order.                                                       
                                      EVIDENCE                                        
               As evidence of obviousness of the claimed subject matter,              
          the examiner relies on the following prior art references:                  
          Reiff et al. (Reiff ‘370) 5,508,370   Apr. 16, 1996                         
          Reiff et al. (Reiff ‘737) 5,693,737   Dec. 2, 1997                          
          Danner     WO 99/52961  Oct. 21, 1999                                       
          (Published International Patent Application)                                
               As evidence of nonobviousness of the claimed subject matter,           
          the appellants rely on the following references:                            
                                          2                                           




Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007