Ex Parte Cattell et al - Page 15




                 Appeal No. 2006-0673                                                                                 Page 15                     
                 Application No. 09/919,555                                                                                                       



                 instructions for the processor on how to read the array or process data from the                                                 
                 array."  (Reply Br. at  17.)                                                                                                     


                         Like the appellants' invention,5 Cattell '351 "relates to arrays, particularly                                           
                 biopolymer arrays (such [as] polynucleotide arrays, and particularly DNA arrays). . . ."                                         
                 (Col. 1, ll. 6-7.)  "FIG. 4 [of the reference] represent[s] an apparatus for producing an                                        
                 addressable array, which is sometimes references herein as a 'fabrication station'.                                              
                 FIG. 4 also illustrates an apparatus for receiving an addressable array, in particular a                                         
                 single 'user station', which is remote from the fabrication station. "  (Col. 10, ll. 5-9.)                                      


                         In the fabrication station, a "local identifier is stored in memory 141 in association                                   
                 with the corresponding unique identifier and array layout."  (Col. 11, ll. 18-20.)  We find                                      
                 that Cattell '351's saving of the local identifier or the unique identifier in the memory 141                                    
                 anticipates the claimed saving of some sort of data in a memory.                                                                 


                         The reference explains that "[p]rocessor 140 then controls the fabricator . . . to                                       
                 generate the one or more arrays on substrate 10 which correspond to the received                                                 



                         5Herbert F. Cattell, the patentee of Catell '351, is one of the co-appellants in the                                     
                 instant case.                                                                                                                    







Page:  Previous  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  16  17  18  19  20  21  22  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007