Ex Parte 5253341 et al - Page 46




               Reexamination Control No. 90/005,742                                                                                   
               Patent 5,253,341                                                                                                       

          1     Id. at col. 1, l. 67 to col. 2, l. 5.  The first type of encoding employed by the system is to replace                
          2    at least some data units with library addresses:                                                                       
          3            [T]he most statistically recurrent portion of the total number of units are                                    
          4            stored in a memory library.  Then the memory library is searched for each                                      
          5            word/unit and if the word/unit is found, the binary address of the                                             
          6            word/unit in the library memory is substituted for the binary data                                             
          7            representing the word/unit together with an appropriate code indicating                                        
          8            that the substitution has been made.  The binary data stream is thus                                           
          9            compressed by compiling a data stream consisting alternatively of units in                                     
         10            the original form, or the addresses of such units in a library memory, with                                    
         11            an "escape code" designating which alternative is used.  Decompression is                                      
         12            then achieved by detecting the address data and fetching the unit from the                                     
         13            same address of an identical library memory.                                                                   
         14                                                                                                                          
         15    Id. at col. 2, ll. 43-57.  This first encoding technique can be supplemented by applying Huffman                       
         16    coding to the data units which are not found in the library memory.  Id.   at col. 3, ll. 28-32.46  The                
         17    library memory can be predetermined and fixed or can be complied in a reconfiguration library                          
         18    as data are being transmitted.  Id.at col. 3, ll. 40-43.                                                               
         19            The examiner's position is that it would have been obvious to modify the compression                           
         20    teaching of Filepp with that of Giltner "[f]or the benefit[s] expressly taught by Giltner et al.                       
         21    (Col. 13, line 65 - col.14, line 67)."  3d Action at 85-86, para. 18; Final Action at 242-43,                          
         22    para. 18.  Some of these benefits are stated as follows:                                                               
         23                    Since the unit 14 can operate at a substantially greater speed than                                    
         24            data can be transmitted over most communications networks, a number of                                         
         25            options are available in the sequence of operation.  For example, as soon                                      
         26            as a portion of a message is received from the local station and stored in                                     
         27            memory, the unit will attempt to establish contact with the designated                                         
         28            remote terminal.  Compression of the message can then begin as soon as a                                       
                                                                                                                                     
                       46   Dr. Koopman's testimony (2d Koopman Decl. at 80, para. 169) that Giltner fails to                         
               disclose two compression modes is therefore not understood.                                                            
                                                            - 46 -                                                                    





Page:  Previous  39  40  41  42  43  44  45  46  47  48  49  50  51  52  53  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007