Ex Parte Cannata et al - Page 20



              Appeal No. 2006-1049                                                                                       
              Application No. 09/667,826                                                                                 

                     61. The Examiner held that given the description of Lung:                                           
                     It would have been obvious to facilitate assembly and maintenance by                                
                     providing the detector array and readout circuit as a single monolithic                             
                     integrated circuit.  The use of output buffers would have depended on                               
                     the intended applications.  It would have been obvious to enhance                                   
                     versatility by providing means to adjust the reference voltage for the                              
                     differential amplifiers. Use of a fixed voltage is conventional.                                    
                     62. The Examiner further held that given the description of Lung:                                   
                     It would have been obvious to simplify assembly and maintenance by                                  
                     structurally integrating the detector elements and readout circuit.  The                            
                     Marsarik (sic) et al focal plane array uses pyroelectric detectors, but it                          
                     would have been obvious that their techniques of offset correction                                  
                     would apply to other types of infrared detectors used in a focal plane                              
                     array, with the type of readout circuit used being dependent on the                                 
                     type of detector.  They amplify detector signals before correcting, but                             
                     it would have been obvious that the amplification step could have                                   
                     been provided after the correction, with such being an obvious design                               
                     choice.                                                                                             
                     63. The Examiner advised applicants that claims 2-4, 8, 14-20, 24, 33-37,                           
              and 45 would be allowable if written in independent form to include all the                                
              limitations of the claims from which they depend.                                                          
                     64. On September 9, 1997, applicants filed an amendment responding to                               
              the Examiner's first Office action.                                                                        




                                                         - 20 -                                                          




Page:  Previous  13  14  15  16  17  18  19  20  21  22  23  24  25  26  27  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007