Ex Parte Friedman et al - Page 6



          Appeal No. 2006-1489                                                        
          Application No. 10/452,059                                                  

          well as shingle or tile types beyond those shown on this page.              
          Similarly, the Rowe patent disclosure is not limited to roofing             
          elements or laminates 36 inches wide and 60 feet long which are             
          packaged in the form of a roll and thus includes roofing elements           
          other the roll forms shown on page 3 of the Manual.                         
               In this latter regard, it is appropriate to emphasize that             
          the 36 inch wide and 60 feet long laminate described in the                 
          paragraph bridging columns 2 and 3 of Rowe is intended to be cut            
          to the particular dimensions required by the roofing substrate              
          which will be covered with the laminate (see the patent                     
          disclosure in its entirety; also see as a supporting comparison             
          the above discussed Manual in its entirety).  In fact, Rowe                 
          expressly teaches that laminate widths more narrow than the                 
          aforementioned 36 inches can be utilized in other roofing                   
          applications (see column 8, lines 51-59) and specifically                   
          discloses a laminate width of 12 inches for use as flashing                 
          strips (id., at lines 59-62).  In applying such a flashing strip            
          to a roofing substrate having, for example, a 40 inch length, it            
          would have been obvious and indeed necessary for an artisan to              
          cut the laminate flashing to a corresponding length of, for                 
          example, 40 inches.                                                         

                                          6                                           




Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007