Ex Parte Powell et al - Page 21


                   Appeal No. 2006-1595                                                                                            
                   Application No. 09/798,484                                                                                      


                   library configuration for hardware modeling simulation in the system of Burgoon                                 
                   to enable modeling the hardware in a higher level language [answer, page 19].                                   
                          The examiner also cites Hellestrand as teaching second logic specifying a                                
                   first configuration of the library when a stand-alone source code simulation is to                              
                   be performed [answer, page 19].  The examiner also cites Martinolle as teaching                                 
                   implementing C functions that are impossible to perform in HDL [answer, page                                    
                   19].  The examiner then concludes that it would have been obvious to the skilled                                
                   artisan at the time of the invention to include second logic specifying a first                                 
                   configuration of the library when a stand-alone simulation is to be performed so                                
                   that modeling could be implemented in a higher-level language such as C and                                     
                   enabling functions to be implemented that are otherwise impossible to implement                                 
                   in HDL [answer, pages 19 and 20].                                                                               
                          The examiner further cites Shinde as teaching specifying a second                                        
                   configuration of the library when a mixed-language simulation is to be performed                                
                   where different configurations enable the library to be used for stand-alone                                    
                   source code simulation and for mixed-language simulation [answer, page 20].                                     
                   The examiner then finds that it would have been obvious to the skilled artisan at                               
                   the time of the invention to include specifying a second configuration of the                                   
                   library when a mixed-language simulation is to be performed where different                                     
                   configurations enable the library to be used for stand-alone source code                                        
                   simulation and for mixed-language simulation to allow verifying the correctness of                              
                   the hardware using multiple models [answer, page 20].                                                           


                                                                21                                                                 



Page:  Previous  11  12  13  14  15  16  17  18  19  20  21  22  23  24  25  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007