Appeal No. 2006-1643 Παγε 24
Application No. 09/845,589
style of three sizes of pictures on the same substrate and
printing them, pictures of different sizes displayed on the
single substrate, these limitations are met because nothing in
the claim requires that different styles are presented to the
user for selection, and in any event, the listing of portrait
sizes and sheet configurations on page 4 of FJCP allows the user
to choose the selection of three different sizes of the same
picture on the same substrate as a page style. In addition,
using the printed pictures to form a collage as taught by Monn
would meet the claim because the claim does not recite who forms
the collage of scrapbook page. From all of the above, we sustain
the rejection of claim 25 for the same reasons as we sustained
the rejection of claims 1, 15 and 23.
We turn next to claim 26. Appellants rely upon the
arguments presented for the reversal of the rejection of claim
25. In addition, appellants assert (brief, page 14) that FJCP
and Monn do not contemplate “automatically selecting a set of
scrapbook page assembly instructions responsive to the style
where the instructions correlate to the series of images.
At the outset, we make reference to our findings, supra,
with respect to the teachings and suggestions of FJCP and Monn.
In FJCP, the user can automatically select the greeting (printed
Page: Previous 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 Next
Last modified: November 3, 2007