Ex Parte Wolf - Page 6


                Appeal No. 2006-2467                                                  Page 6                 
                Application No. 10/157,644                                                                   

                contain 10.5, 3.1 and 17 grams of fructose, respectively, and juices such as                 
                orange juice and apple juice contain 7.4 and 13.9 grams of fructose, respectively.           
                The examiner notes that Lundstrom “does not specify the instant time period,”                
                “the inherent mechanism in which fructose works,” and “the instant form of                   
                fructose.”  Id. at 7.                                                                        
                      Moore teaches the administration of glucose with or without 7.5 grams of               
                fructose, with blood samples being drawn every 15 to 120 minutes.  See id.                   
                Moore is also relied upon for teaching that their findings “hold promise for the             
                improvement of carbohydrate tolerance in individuals with impaired glucose                   
                tolerance and diabetes.”  See id.                                                            
                      Anderson is relied upon as in the previous rejection.  See id.                         
                      The examiner again concludes:                                                          
                            It would have been obvious to one of ordinary skill in the art                   
                      at the time the invention was made to manipulate when the fructose                     
                      snack, i.e. fruit or fruit juice, is administered since Lundstrom                      
                      teaches that the purpose of a well-balanced meal is to maintain the                    
                      blood sugar level and it depends on an array of factors based on                       
                      the individual.  Lundstrom further teaches these factors that are                      
                      known to a skilled artisan consist of an individual’s weight, age, and                 
                      condition of the patient such as whether the patient takes insulin or                  
                      other antidiabetic medications, and the blood sugar profile                            
                      determined by a finger stick.  For instance, one would have been                       
                      motivated to consume Kauffman’s [sic] therapeutic composition                          
                      prior to a meal, if one’s sugar profile was near hypoglycemia (low                     
                      blood sugar level) and the time in which the next meal is consumed                     
                      depends on the blood sugar level.  It is obvious that a meal would                     
                      not be immediately consumed with the                                                   











Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007