Ex Parte Escobosa et al - Page 10




          Appeal No. 2006-2475                                                              
          Application No. 10/411,792                                                        
                                                                                           
          it obvious to do so in order to select the appliance to be                        
          controlled (See page 6, lines 11-20, of Kemink for a display of                   
          the list of appliances with corresponding graphic user interface                  
          code, and a selection by the user), but Kemink does not teach                     
          displaying a plurality of pre-programmed sequences, or macros,                    
          accessed by an Internet Web site.  When a user selects a graphic                  
          interface code, it is downloaded from the Internet Web site (See                  
          page 6, lines 16-18, of Kemink).  Thus, Kemink also teaches                       
          accepting from a user at the client computer a selection of at                    
          least one of a plurality of graphic interface codes for                           
          downloading from the Internet Web site for use in the remote                      
          control.                                                                          
                Therefore, Kemink describes the use of macros, or pre-                      
          programmed sequences, and the use of an Internet Web site for                     
          accessing a plurality of graphic interface codes, as well as                      
          displaying to the user a plurality of those codes and accepting                   



          from the user a selection of at least one of the codes for                        
          downloading from the Internet Web site for use in the remote                      
          control.  The only thing missing from Kemink is that it is the                    
          macros, or pre-programmed sequences, which are listed, selected,                  
          displayed, accepted, and downloaded.                                              
                But, van Ee clearly teaches that macros, or pre-programmed                  

                                            10                                              





Page:  Previous  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  16  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007