Appeal No. 2006-2752 Application No. 10/309,007 disclosure of what arrangement of rectifier is used with the annular arrangement of five phase windings. In this situation, the rectifier may be less than five phases. To determine whether claim 1 is anticipated, we must first determine the scope of the claim. We note that representative claim 1 reads in part as follows: [S]aid armature winding is constructed by connecting five winding phase portions into an annular shape such that the electrical angular phases of electromotive force differ from each other by approximately 72 degrees. At page 8, paragraph 44, Appellants’ specification states the following: [0044] The stator 8 is provided with: a stator core 15; and an armature winding 16 installed in the stator core 15. This armature winding 16 is constructed into a five-phase armature winding by connecting five winding phase portions 31a to 31e, including an a-phase winding phase portion 31a, a b-phase winding phase portion 31b, a c-phase winding phase portion 31c, a d-phase winding phase portion 31d, and an e- phase winding phase portion 31e, into an annular shape (a ring connection) so as to have a phase difference corresponding to an electrical angle of 72 degrees from each other. Connection portions between each pair of adjacent winding phase portions are connected to respective connection portions between a positive-side diode d1 and a negative-side diode d2. Thus, representative claim 1 does require an armature winding being constructed by connecting five winding phase portions into an annular shape to be rectified by a five phase full wave rectifier. Now, the question before us is what Buening would have 7Page: Previous 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 NextLast modified: November 3, 2007