Ex Parte Eckl - Page 5

            Appeal Number: 2006-1650                                                                          
            Application Number: 09/903,500                                                                    

                                Transmittal of the invoice to each debtor is contemplated                     
                         in two ways. In today's business environment a shipping envelope is                  
                         routinely required.  However, in the future, it is contemplated for                  
                         transmittal of invoices and invoice payments to be accomplished                      
                         electronically and for the existence of transmittal charges for such                 
                         electronic transmittal. The present invention can be used in an all-                 
                         electronic business environment whereby, for the debtor's                            
                         convenience in being allowed to make return payments electronically,                 
                         the debtor signs a print written agreement that he authorizes being                  
                         billed on his or her invoice for electronic transmittal charges that                 
                         would otherwise be incurred by the creditor for such electronic return               
                         payment and for which the creditor would be unwilling to pay[.]                      
                         Should envelopes be required, the computer will determine whether                    
                         an address is needed for either the shipping envelope or the pre-paid                
                         return envelope. If addresses are required, the computer will direct a               
                         printer to print the creditor's address on the pre-paid return envelope              
                         and the debtor's current address on the shipping envelope. It is not                 
                         critical to the present invention which envelope is printed first. The               
                         computer will then direct a postage metering device to print                         
                         transmittal charges onto the shipping envelope and onto the return                   
                         envelope as needed. Again, it is not critical to the present invention               
                         which envelope is printed first. The computer-aided billing system                   
                         will then have the computer direct the collation or assembly of the                  
                         pre-paid return envelope, the shipping envelope, and the invoice                     
                         for transmittal to the customer. This process is repeated for each                   
                         successive debtor in the database. As the operating speeds of printers               
                         and postage metering devices are variable, the order of the steps                    
                         included herein may be varied to the extent necessary to maximize                    
                         the efficiency of each printer and each postage metering device used                 
                         by a creditor without departing from the fundamental intent of the                   
                         present invention. (Emphasis supplied).                                              

                                          PRINCIPLES OF LAW                                                   
                   “A claimed invention is unpatentable if the differences between it and the                 
            prior art are such that the subject matter as a whole would have been obvious at the              
            time the invention was made to a person having ordinary skill in the pertinent art.”              

                                                      5                                                       

Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  Next

Last modified: September 9, 2013