Ex Parte Apps - Page 2

                 Appeal 2006-2032                                                                                    
                 Application 09/891,948                                                                              
                        Appellant's invention is a low depth tray for bottles comprising first                       
                 and second pairs of opposing walls and interior columns, wherein the                                
                 interior columns have a height less than that of at least one of the pairs of                       
                 opposing walls.  Claim 1 is illustrative of the invention and reads as follows:                     
                                     1. A low depth tray for bottles, comprising:                                    
                                     a first pair of opposed walls;                                                  
                                     a second pair of opposed walls attached to                                      
                              the first pair of opposed walls to form a wall                                         
                              structure having an interior, the second pair of                                       
                              opposed walls longer than the first pair of opposed                                    
                              walls;                                                                                 
                                     a base attached to the wall structure;                                          
                                     a plurality of interior divider walls extending                                 
                              upwardly from the interior of the wall structure;                                      
                              and                                                                                    
                                     at least one interior member projecting                                         
                              upwardly from the interior of the wall structure                                       
                              and connected to at least one divider wall, the at                                     
                              least one interior member having a height less than                                    
                              an uppermost height of the second pair of opposed                                      
                              walls and less than the height of bottles loaded in                                    
                              the tray,                                                                              
                                     wherein the at least one interior member, the                                   
                              base, the divider walls, and the wall structure                                        
                              define a plurality of bottle retaining pockets which                                   
                              are each sized to receive a single bottle therein.                                     

                        The Examiner relies upon the following as evidence of                                        
                 unpatentability:                                                                                    
                 Sauey                     US 2,928,530                Mar. 15, 1960                                
                 Apps ‘002                  US 4,978,002                Dec. 18, 1990                                
                 Apps ‘279                  US 5,660,279                Aug. 26, 1997                                
                 McGrath                   US 6,047,844                Apr. 11, 2000                                
                 Apps ‘793                  US 6,073,793                Jun. 13, 2000                                
                 Hammett                   US 6,079,554                Jun. 27, 2000                                

                                                         2                                                           

Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  Next

Last modified: September 9, 2013