Ex Parte Bale et al - Page 5

             Appeal Number: 2006-3054                                                                          
             Application Number: 10/672,625                                                                    

                   A conflict resolution scheme is defined by the specification as a sheme                     
             which resolve conflicts between two control schemes [0040].  The conflict                         
             resolution scheme has rules concerning how to resolve conflicts between control                   
             schemes.  The specification discloses:                                                            
                          These conflict control rules may be absolute(e.g., “Safety                           
                          scheme rules are always given priority over actuator                                 
                          control scheme rules.”), or may depend upon sensed                                   
                          conditions of the vehicle (e.g., “When condition A is                                
                          sensed, the rule contained in actuator control scheme X is                           
                          given priority over the rule contained in actuator control                           
                          scheme Y”).[0040]                                                                    
                          . . . conflict rules help resolve conflicts at the control                           
                          level.  With such a system, for example, inherent                                    
                          conflicts existing between antilock braking, traction,                               
                          manual inputs/outputs, and other vehicle dynamics                                    
                          schemes no longer lead to “lost” or cycling braking                                  
                          systems creating a safety hazard [0041].                                             
                   A person of ordinary skill in the art would be informed by this language of                 
             the specification how to make and use a conflict resolution scheme.                               
                   Phoenix discloses an electronic braking control system which includes, as                   
             depicted in Figure 1, a plurality of brake components 20, a vehicle performance                   
             sensor or wheel speed sensor 26, and a central control unit 10 (col. 5, line 54 to col.           
             6, lines 5).  The central control unit 10 receives sensor signals from the sensors 26             
             and generates a control signal for controlling the brake components 20 (Figure 3).                
             A distributed electronic control unit 16 also receives the sensor signals from the                
             vehicle sensors 26 and controls some of the brake components 20.  In operation,                   
             the central controller 10 controls the brake components by receiving signals from                 
             the sensors 26 through line 26 and through delay 44a.  The central control unit 10                


                                                      5                                                        

Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  Next

Last modified: September 9, 2013