Ex Parte Honma et al - Page 2



             Appeal No. 2006-3405                                                                                
             Application No. 10/631,858                                                                          

                                               BACKGROUND                                                        
                   The invention relates to a dielectric device in which constituent elements in                 
             an electrode surface layer that abuts a dielectric film are terminated by halogen                   
             (fluorine) atoms.  According to appellants, the arrangement provides for superior                   
             characteristics with respect to dielectric devices in the prior art.  Claim 1, the sole             
             independent claim on appeal, is reproduced below.                                                   
                   1.     A dielectric device comprising:                                                        
                          such a first electrode layer that constituent elements located on its                  
                   surface are terminated by halogen atoms; and                                                  
                          a dielectric film formed on the surface of said first electrode layer                  
                   terminated by said halogen atoms,                                                             
                          wherein said first electrode layer contains at least one element selected              
                   from a group consisting of Pt, Ir, Pd and Ru and said halogen atoms are                       
                   fluorine atoms.                                                                               
                   The examiner relies on the following references:                                              
             Fukaya et al. (Fukaya)           US 4,581,099               Apr.   8, 1986                          
             Yamazaki et al. (Yamazaki)       US 6,046,469               Apr.   4, 2000                          
             Kirlin et al. (Kirlin)                 US 6,320,213 B1           Nov. 20, 2001                     


                                                       -2-                                                       



Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  Next

Last modified: September 9, 2013