Ex Parte 5573648 et al - Page 18



            Appeal 2007-0128                                                                                  
            Reexamination Control 90/006,208                                                                  
            Patent 5,573,648                                                                                  


            36) LaConti Table I lists a variety of gases that can be detected including carbon                
            monoxide, nitric oxide, alcohol, hydrogen, oxides of sulfur, hydrogen sulfide,                    
            chlorine, bromine and oxygen.  (LaConti, Table 1).                                                

                         vi. Tomantschger, U.S. Patent 5,302,274                                              
            37) The Examiner states that Dempsey, Grot and Uchida fail to Aexplicitly recite                  
            the use of a hydrated metal oxide protonic conductor electrolyte.@  (Examiner=s                   
            Answer, p. 7).                                                                                    


            38) Tomantschger teaches a gas sensor cell for quantitative measurement of                        
            volatile gas components.  (Tomantschger, abstract).                                               

            39) Tomantschger states that a specific gas sensor cell system can be devised                     
            using suitable catalysts and electrolytes to test for any toxic, combustible or                   
            flammable gas.  (Id. at col. 2, ll. 42-46).                                                       

            40) Tomantschger’s gas sensor cell comprises a sensing electrode and a counter                    
            electrode on either side of an ion conductive electrolyte.  (Id. at abstract).                    

            41) Tomantschger teaches that the sensor and electrolyte are chosen to produce a                  

                                                     18                                                       



Page:  Previous  11  12  13  14  15  16  17  18  19  20  21  22  23  24  25  Next

Last modified: September 9, 2013