Ex Parte Vu - Page 5



             Appeal No. 2007-0204                                                                  
             Application 10/938,966                                                                
             image in the invention means "switching off" the slice-encoding and rewinder          
             gradients.  Lastly, the only other places the term "disabled" is mentioned in         
             the Specification are at two places describing that the inventive method of           
             MR data acquisition                                                                   
                   includes prescribing a 3D imaging volume, applying a pulse sequence             
                   that is applicable as a 3D pulse sequence with slice encoding and               
                   rewinder gradients disabled in one dimension, and acquiring 2D MR               
                   data to localize the 3D imaging volume. After the 3D imaging volume             
                   is localized, the disabled slice encoding and rewinder gradients are            
                   enabled and the technique continues by applying the pulse sequence in           
                   three dimensions and acquiring 3D MR data of the 3D                             
                   imaging volume.  [Emphasis added.]                                              
             (Pages 3 and 12.)  The term "disabled" is plainly used in the sense of being          
             opposite to "enabled"; i.e., "disabled" means "turned off" or "inactivated,"          
             whereas "enabled" means "turned on" or "activated."  There is absolutely no           
             suggestion that "disabled" means "only partly turned off."                            
                   While it may be true that "disabled" does not always have to mean               
             "disabled completely" or "turned off" or "inactivated," the embodiment in             
             Figures 2, 3, and 4 shows the gradients "disabled completely" and there is no         
             suggestion that "disabled" to acquire a 2D image means anything other than            
             "turned off" or "inactivated."  As to Appellant's argument that the fact that         
             gradients are completely turned off in the embodiment in Figure 3 does not            
             dictate the conclusion that all "disabled" gradients are completely turned off,       
             Appellant has not pointed to any language which would suggest that                    
             "disabled," as used in this application and as described as being the                 

                                               - 5 -                                               



Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  Next

Last modified: September 9, 2013