Ex Parte Kappel et al - Page 5



                Appeal 2007-0226                                                                                  
                Application 09/823,866                                                                            
                (Final Rejection 2).  This statement seems to say that the Examiner considers                     
                a "client" and "server" to be "objects," instead of functions and procedures                      
                on the client and server.  However, since Schmidt describes "wrapper                              
                facades" whose purpose is "to encapsulate low-level functions and data                            
                structures with object-oriented (OO) class interfaces" (Schmidt, p. 1 under                       
                "Introduction") for use in networking applications (Schmidt, p. 3 under                           
                "Problem" and "Solution"), i.e., encapsulation of objects, we interpret the                       
                rejection, in context, to be that the "wrapper facade" in Schmidt provides                        
                access to objects on the clients and server in the networking environment.                        
                       The Examiner continues by finding that Schmidt teaches "means for                          
                identifying at least two objects (one being the client and one being                              
                database/printer service) from a plurality of objects (client, database, printer,                 
                console services/functions) to communicate (invoke/request service)                               
                [fig.s [sic] 1, 3" (Final Rejection 2).  Again, while this seems to say that the                  
                physical objects of client computer, database, printer, and console in                            
                Figure 1 are "objects," in the context of Schmidt, we interpret the rejection                     
                to be that "objects," in the sense of functions or procedures, on the client                      
                computer, database, printer, etc. in Figure 1 are in communication.                               
                       The Examiner further finds that Schmidt "means for locating the at                         
                least two objects to communicate (socket handles) [page 1, right col.; page 6,                    
                right col., 2nd code listing" (Final Rejection 2).  The two objects (one on the                   
                client and one on the server) communicate via "socket handles" which are                          
                ports at a certain IP address.                                                                    

                                                        5                                                         



Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  Next

Last modified: September 9, 2013