Ex Parte Kappel et al - Page 8



                Appeal 2007-0226                                                                                  
                Application 09/823,866                                                                            
                Schmidt has to have "means for identifying at least two objects . . . from a                      
                plurality of objects to communicate" because it must know to connect the                          
                logging record sent by the client to the program on the server which                              
                processes the records.  Schmidt must also have "means for locating the at                         
                least two objects to communicate" in order to be able to connect the object                       
                on the client with the object on the logging server.                                              
                       Schmidt does not expressly teach "two objects in separate and distinct                     
                server locations."  Note that this limitation does not recite "objects that                       
                reside on separate servers" (Br. 11), as argued by Appellants; technically, the                   
                "separate and distinct server locations" could be in different address                            
                locations in the same server.  A "server" is usually defined as a computer                        
                system in a network that is shared by multiple users.  Stand-alone PCs can                        
                function as a server to other users on the network even though they serve as                      
                a single workstation to one user.  The logging server in Schmidt is clearly a                     
                server.  Schmidt shows communication from a "client" to the server.  A                            
                "client" is a computer that requests a service from a server.  Although the                       
                client computers in Schmidt could serve multiple users, and thus be a server,                     
                this is not disclosed.                                                                            
                       Konrad discloses a system which allows a computer user at a local                          
                host to access information services on a remote host which are as easy to                         
                access as services on the local host (e.g., col. 4, ll. 6-14).  In a "client-server-              
                service (CSS)" model, a "client" process makes demands on a "server"                              
                process, which then satisfies these demands using a "service" process (col. 6,                    

                                                        8                                                         



Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  Next

Last modified: September 9, 2013