Ex Parte Johnson - Page 5



                Appeal 2007-0349                                                                             
                Application 09/862,355                                                                       
                identity attribute, an IP address or a client based log" (id.).  Thus,                       
                "[a]ccording to the Sitaraman et al. patent, a first time user in a group may                
                be count limited from a proxy session just because other members of the                      
                group reached the group count limit" (Br. 7), whereas "Appellant's invention                 
                can avoid this drawback of the Sitaraman system using a predetermined                        
                threshold value that relates to a particular client process based on a source                
                identity associated with a client process, an IP address or a client process log             
                to limit the number of sessions between a server and a particular client                     
                process, rather than limiting sessions within a given domain" (id.).                         
                      The Examiner finds (Answer 11) that the claimed "source identity                       
                attribute associated with said client process" in claim 1 it taught by the                   
                statement "[t]he local database contains a group identification such as a                    
                domain identification corresponding to a group of users" (Sitaraman, col. 3,                 
                ll. 21-23).  The Examiner finds (id.) that the claimed "client process"                      
                corresponds to a "user of CorpA" and the claimed "server process"                            
                corresponds to a "proxy session," referring to column 5, lines 14-26.  The                   
                Examiner finds that Sitaraman describes a source identity attribute, an IP                   
                address, or a client based log at column 1, line 59 through column 2, line 20,               
                and column 5, lines 28-35 (Answer 12-14).                                                    

                      Claims 1-8                                                                             
                            Issue                                                                            
                      The issue is whether determining whether to establish a new session                    
                between a user and a proxy server based on a "group identification such as a                 
                                                     5                                                       



Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  Next

Last modified: September 9, 2013