Ex Parte Johnson - Page 7



                Appeal 2007-0349                                                                             
                Application 09/862,355                                                                       
                      Claims 14-16                                                                           
                            Issue                                                                            
                      The issue is whether determining whether to grant a request to                         
                establish a new session between a user and a proxy server in Sitaraman                       
                based on a "group identification such as a domain identification                             
                corresponding to a group of users" anticipates the following limitations of                  
                claim 14:                                                                                    
                            a log memory . . . relating to sessions between said server                      
                            process and any client process; and a session monitor associated                 
                            with said server process to determine from said log information                  
                            whether to grant a request to establish a new session from said                  
                            client process and limit a number of sessions active between the                 
                            server process and the client process to a predetermined                         
                            threshold value.                                                                 

                            Analysis                                                                         
                      Sitaraman maintains a log of the number of sessions for members of a                   
                "group of users."  It does not maintain a log "relating to sessions between                  
                said server process and any client process" and does not "determine from                     
                said log information whether to grant a request to establish a new session                   
                from said client process and limit a number of sessions active between the                   
                server process and the client process to a predetermined threshold value."                   
                Even if we accept the Examiner's interpretation that a "user" is a "client                   
                process," which we do not, Sitaraman does not limit the number of sessions                   
                between the user and the server: it limits the number of sessions for a "group               

                                                     7                                                       



Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  Next

Last modified: September 9, 2013