Ex Parte Wollenberg et al - Page 6

                Appeal 2007-0511                                                                                 
                Application 10/699,508                                                                           
            1          According to the Appellants’ Specification, various means for                             
            2   oxidation stability testing are known and generally include subjecting a                         
            3   sample to an oxygen environment and measuring the effect of oxidation on                         
            4   the sample over a predetermined period of time.  Specification, p. 24, ll. 10-                   
            5   12.                                                                                              
            6          The Appellants disclose several oxidation stability tests.                                
            7   Specification, p. 24, l. 13-p. 29, l. 8.                                                         
            8          The Appellants define “program control” as meaning that the                               
            9   equipment used to provide the plurality of lubricating oil compositions is                       
           10   automated and controlled by a microprocessor or other computer control                           
           11   device.  Specification, p. 5, ll. 19-21.                                                         
           12                2.     Kolosov                                                                      
           13          The invention disclosed in Kolosov relates to high throughput screens                     
           14   for evaluating the rheological properties of a material.  Kolosov, para.                         
           15   [0002].                                                                                          
           16          According to Kolosov, combinatorial chemistry refers generally to                         
           17   methods for synthesizing a collection of chemically diverse materials and to                     
           18   methods for rapidly testing or screening the collection of materials for                         
           19   desirable performance characteristics.  Combinatorial chemistry approaches                       
           20   have greatly improved the efficiency of discovery of useful materials.                           
           21   Kolosov, para. [0004].                                                                           
           22          The disclosed invention may be used to screen or test flowable                            
           23   materials such as lubricants.  Kolosov, para. [0042].                                            
           24          The invention is said to have particular utility in connection with                       
           25   screening a number of different material forms including oils.  Kolosov,                         
           26   para. [0043].                                                                                    

                                                       6                                                         

Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  Next

Last modified: September 9, 2013