Ex Parte Carpenter et al - Page 2

            Appeal 2007-0645                                                                               
            Application 10/242,898                                                                         

        1                                     INVENTION                                                    
        2                                                                                                  
        3         The invention is directed to a document exchange system in which security                
        4   is integral to the system.  See pages 3 and 4 of Appellants’ Specification.  Claim 1           
        5   is representative of the invention and reproduced below:                                       
        6                1. A document exchange environment for allowing a user to access                  
        7         documents, the document exchange environment comprising:                                 
        8                a web server;                                                                     
        9                a document vault database coupled to the web server, the document                 
       10                      vault database storing information regarding whether a user is              
       11                      authorized to access a document file;                                       
       12                a file server coupled to the web server, the file server providing a user         
       13                      access to the document file via the web server based upon the               
       14                      information regarding whether the user is authorized to access              
       15                      the document file.                                                          
       16                                                                                                  
       17                                    REFERENCES                                                    
       18                                                                                                  
       19         The references relied upon by the Examiner are:                                          
       20                                                                                                  
       21                Prompt   US 2001/0034733 A1  Oct. 25, 2001                                        
       22                                                (filed Mar. 02, 2001)                             
       23                Sitka   US 6,330,572 B1   Dec. 11, 2001                                           
       24                                               (effectively filed Jul. 15, 1998)                  
       25                                                                                                  
       26                                REJECTION AT ISSUE                                                
       27         Claims 1 through 241 stand rejected under 35 U.S.C. § 103(a) as                          
       28   unpatentable over Prompt and Sitka.  The Examiner’s rejection is set forth on                  
                                                                                                          
            1 We note that the statement of the rejection identifies claims 1-17 as being                  
            rejected, but the reasoning in support of the rejection also addresses claims 18               
            through 24.  Appellants’ arguments similarly address the rejection as applied to               
            claims 1 through 24.  Accordingly, we consider the Examiner’s rejection on appeal              
            to apply to claims 1 through 24.                                                               
                                                     2                                                     


Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  Next

Last modified: September 9, 2013