Ex Parte Carpenter et al - Page 6

            Appeal 2007-0645                                                                               
            Application 10/242,898                                                                         

        1         Appellants’ specification on page 7 states “[t]he algorithm determines                   
        2   whether the user is explicitly assigned to the requested file or folder.”  Thus, the           
        3   scope of the term security algorithm includes an algorithm that checks user access             
        4   to a file or folder.  As discussed supra, we find that Sitka teaches the use of                
        5   algorithms to determine a user’s authorization to access files. Thus, contrary to              
        6   Appellants’ arguments, we find ample evidence to support the Examiner’s finding                
        7   that Sitka teaches the claimed security database and algorithm.                                
        8                                                                                                  
        9                                       CONCLUSION                                                 
       10         We find for the Examiner as we find that Sitka teaches the claimed                       
       11   “document vault database” and “security database and algorithm portion.”  Thus,                
       12   Appellants’ arguments have not persuaded us of error in the Examiner’s rejections              
       13   of claims 1 through 24 under 35 U.S.C. § 103(a).  Accordingly, we sustain this                 
       14   rejection.  The decision of the Examiner is affirmed.                                          
       15         No time period for taking any subsequent action in connection with this                  
       16   appeal may be extended under 37 C.F.R. § 1.136(a)(1)(iv) (2006).                               
       17                                                                                                  
       18                                      AFFIRMED                                                    
       19                                                                                                  
       20                                                                                                  
       21                                                                                                  
       22                                                                                                  
       23   vsh                                                                                            
       24   HAMILTON & TERRILE, LLP                                                                        
       25   P.O. BOX 203518                                                                                
       26   AUSTIN TX 78720                                                                                


                                                     6                                                     


Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6

Last modified: September 9, 2013