Ex Parte Kuruoglu et al - Page 2

                Appeal 2007-0666                                                                               
                Application 09/738,992                                                                         
                                                A. INVENTION                                                   
                      The invention at issue on appeal "provides a collaborative annotation                    
                technique in which users can make handwritten annotations to original paper                    
                documents."  (Specification 2.)  According to the technique, each user                         
                employs a device to capture a digital image of a paper document including                      
                any handwritten annotations thereon.  The image is processed to extract                        
                images corresponding to the annotations, and the extracted images are                          
                distributed to the other users for display.  Each user may, therefore, view a                  
                combined image of the document on which the individual annotations are                         
                overlaid.  Because users prefer to handle, and to make annotations on, a                       
                paper document rather than on an electronic representation thereof, assert the                 
                Appellants, theirs is "the most convenient technique for a user."  (Id.)                       

                                                  B. CLAIM                                                     
                      Claim 1, which further illustrates the invention, follows.                               
                      1. A system for permitting collaborative annotation of a                                 
                      hardcopy document, the system comprising:                                                
                             a plurality of workstations each comprising a computer                            
                      processor, a display, and a capture device for capturing a digital                       
                      image of a hardcopy document; and                                                        
                             a base computer communicating with the plurality of                               
                      workstations;                                                                            
                             wherein the system is operative to:                                               
                             (a) identify handwritten annotations in digital images of                         
                      the hardcopy document captured at each workstation;                                      



                                                      2                                                        

Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  Next

Last modified: September 9, 2013