Appeal 2007-0666
Application 09/738,992
Absent a teaching or suggestion of transmitting, to each of a plurality
of workstations, data representing handwritten annotations that were made to
a paper document via at least two of the workstations, and displaying at least
one of the handwritten annotations at each of the workstations, we are
unpersuaded of a prima facie case of obviousness. Therefore, we reverse the
rejection of claims 1, 11, and 12, and of claims 2-6, 8-10, 13-17, and 19-22,
which depend therefrom.
The Examiner does not allege, let alone show, that the addition of
Levine cures the aforementioned deficiency of Carleton, Tran, Simonoff,
and Cass. Therefore, we also reverse the rejection of these claims.
V. ORDER
In summary, the rejections of claims 1-22 under § 103(a) are reversed.
REVERSED
pgc
John E. Beck
Xerox Corporation
Xerox Square-20A
Rochester NY 14644
9
Page: Previous 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9
Last modified: September 9, 2013