Ex Parte Gianotti - Page 6

                    Appeal 2007-1197                                                                                                    
                    Application 10/674,729                                                                                              

                                   wherein at selected crossing points, each of the first wire                                          
                            and the second wire is shaped to form an elevation 24 extended                                              
                            away from the braided tubular wall in a selected direction                                                  
                            radially of the braided tubular wall; and                                                                   
                                   wherein said elevations are arranged in at least one                                                 
                            elevation pattern on the braided tubular wall, and the at least                                             
                            one elevation pattern has a third pitch different from the first                                            
                            pitch and different from the second pitch.                                                                  
                    (Answer 3.)                                                                                                         
                            Again, the relevance of Chuter is dependent on the interpretation of                                        
                    claim 31.  The Examiner finds that the Appellant's Specification does not                                           
                    define the term "substantially" with respect to the first and second pitch of                                       
                    the wire in claim 31.  (Answer 5.)                                                                                  
                            The Examiner contends                                                                                       
                                   Appellant has not claimed that the pitch is "constant" but                                           
                            only has to be "substantially constant".  Further, with reference                                           
                            to the claims, it is not stated that the windings are of a                                                  
                            substantially constant pitch [ ] over the entire . . . length of the                                        
                            stent.  With that is [sic] mind, one can reasonably state that with                                         
                            reference to the device of Churter [sic], the wires in a                                                    
                            longitudinally oriented section 26 are of a substantially constant                                          
                            pitch in that section.                                                                                      
                                   Finally, referring to figure 1 of Chuter, looking at the                                             
                            entire length, the stent is comprised of sections 26 and 24.                                                
                            Windings 10 in sections 26 have a substantially constant pitch;                                             
                            sections 26 further make up a larger percentage or a                                                        
                            "substantial" portion of the stent's length and, therefore, the                                             
                            winding[s] are "substantially constant" over the entire length of                                           
                            the stent.                                                                                                  
                    (Answer 5.)                                                                                                         


                                                                   6                                                                    

Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  Next

Last modified: September 9, 2013