Ex Parte Gondhalekar et al - Page 2


               Appeal 2007-1228                                                                        
               Application 10/150,458                                                                  
           1   (2006) from a final rejection of claims 1-9.  Examiner's Answer entered                 
           2   September 7, 2006.                                                                      
           3         Claims 10-21 are appear in the application on appeal, but have been               
           4   withdrawn from further consideration as being drawn to non-elected species.             
           5   Office Action entered October 10, 2003, page 2; Appeal Brief filed June 23,             
           6   2006, page 2.                                                                           
           7         The application on appeal has been published as U.S. Patent                       
           8   Application Publication 2003/0213434 A1 (20 November 2003).                             
           9         We have jurisdiction under 35 U.S.C. § 6(b) (2006).                               
          10         As a result of a requirement for an election of species, Applied                  
          11   Materials elected to prosecute the species shown as Fig. 5 in the drawings of           
          12   the application on appeal.                                                              
          13         While claim 1-9 read on the elected embodiment of Fig. 5, claim 6 is              
          14   limited to the Fig. 5 embodiment.                                                       
          15         With reference to Fig. 1 and Fig. 5 of the drawings, claim 1 reads as             
          16   follows [bracketed material added]:                                                     
          17               An apparatus for processing semiconductor substrates, the                   
          18         apparatus comprising:                                                             
          19                  [1] a chamber [Fig. 1; element 1] defining a plasma                      
          20            processing region [Fig. 1, element 16] therein, the chamber                    
          21            including a bottom, a side wall, and a dome [Fig. 1, element 14]               
          22            disposed on top of the side wall, the dome having a substantially              
          23            flat dome top;                                                                 
          24                  [2] a top RF coil [Fig. 5, element 102] disposed above the               
          25            dome top, the top RF coil having an outer loop which is larger in              
          26            size than the substrates to be processed in the chamber;                       



                                                  2                                                    


Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  Next

Last modified: September 9, 2013